Sherlock Holmes Double Feature

Comments

Any book that has Holmes married is a non-starter, IMHO. (Then again, I do not like to read books by lesser authors who use someone else's creations rather than build their won worlds to play in.)

The misogyny and comments on the lower classes are par for the course in 1887; Doyle actually got in trouble from some of his contemporaries for showing the underclass in a good light. For comparison, see Twain's use of "the n-word" in Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn, Dickens' portrayal of prostitutes and thieves in Oliver Twist, and Steinbeck's comments on the races in The Harvest Gypsies.

John
I'm not at all fond of Dickens. I think he was a real Ass with a capital A. That being said, a small few (and only a small few) are worth reading. Mark Twain had his own issues, and so did Steinbeck. I think that sometimes you have to overlook things in order to read and enjoy the good fiction of less enlightened societies.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in